The text was still open on my phone when I set it facedown on the kitchen counter. I didn’t delete it. I didn’t answer it either.

I’d been with Eric for three years and nine months. We’d talked about marriage and buying a house, and I thought we were close to deciding what the next few years would look like. Then I burped while we were kissing, and Eric got out of bed and drove home.

It was a small sound. I’d had sparkling water earlier. I covered my mouth and said I was sorry.

Eric looked disgusted, and I laughed because I thought he had to be kidding.

He wasn’t.

The next morning, he sent a numbered list of things I needed to stop doing if I wanted him to propose. Burping and passing gas. Wearing old pajamas. Talking about my period unless there was an emergency. Leaving hair in the shower. Using the bathroom with the door open, which I don’t do.

I read that one twice. I still don’t know why it bothered me so much. Maybe because it made the list feel less like a reaction to something I’d done and more like Eric had been keeping track.

The flowers he’d brought the day before were on my counter. I’d moved them once to wipe up a ring of water underneath the vase. Then I moved them back. I kept doing that while I tried to decide what the disagreement actually was.

My sister said I should end it. My best friend said Eric’s expectations were out of line, but four years was a long time to throw away over one gross reaction. I understood both of them. I also got tired of hearing the same version of the question: Was one burp worth ending a relationship?

I wrote something down on the back of a grocery receipt. Being considerate is mutual. My body is not a promise.

It looked almost silly there beside a list of what I needed at the store. But it helped me see what I was trying to ask. I wasn’t asking Eric to enjoy every habit I had. I was asking whether he thought normal, sometimes involuntary things made me less fit to marry.

So I texted him.

“Can we talk in person? About the list and marriage.”

He answered a little while later. “Okay. I can come by tonight.”

I almost told him not to. I was still mad about the night he left, and I didn’t want to hear myself get softened up by flowers and cheesecake again. But I also didn’t want to make a decision based on what I guessed he meant.

That evening, Eric came over without anything in his hands. I noticed that, then felt stupid for noticing. We sat at my kitchen table. The flowers were still on the counter between us, slightly droopy by then.

Eric rubbed the edge of the table with his thumb. “I’m sorry I left like that.”

I said, “Are you sorry you made the list?”

He paused. “I don’t want to control you.”

That wasn’t what I’d asked.

I put my phone on the table and opened the text. “Do you still expect these things in a marriage?”

“I expect us to make an effort for each other.”

“I agree with that. I’m asking about the list.”

Eric looked down at the screen. “I wrote it because I was upset.

But I meant what I said about wanting some things kept private.”

I asked him what that meant if I was sick. Or exhausted. Or pregnant. We’d already talked about pregnancy on the phone, and I hadn’t forgotten his answer. He’d said he’d support me, but that didn’t mean I should stop trying.

Eric leaned back a little. “I’d support you.”

“I know you said that.”

“I don’t expect you to look perfect every second.”

I asked whether he expected me not to burp, pass gas, talk about my period, or wear old pajamas around him. He said he didn’t expect perfection. Then he said the same thing again, that he wanted me to try.

I kept coming back to that word. Try. It was a plain word, and he used it like it explained everything.

“Try to do what?” I asked. “Not have a body?”

His face tightened. “That’s not fair.”

I could feel myself getting sharp, and I knew that wasn’t helping. I can be stubborn when I’m scared, and I was scared that if I let the conversation go soft, I’d walk away with no answer. So I kept the phone on the table.

“Do you think the same rules should apply to you?”

Eric didn’t answer right away. He said he didn’t want to talk about himself as if we were keeping score.

“I’m not keeping score. I’m asking if you’d follow the same rules.”

He looked uncomfortable. “I’m a man. It’s different.”

I had heard that before, when he told me I was supposed to be feminine. But hearing it now, with the list open between us, made it harder to pretend I’d misunderstood him.

I said, “So you get to be a person, and I have to be careful not to seem like one.”

He rubbed his forehead. “That’s not what I’m saying.”

I waited. He didn’t offer a different way to say it.

We sat there for a while. I could hear the refrigerator kick on. I remember that because it made me think of my sister’s kitchen, where the same little rattle starts before the motor catches. It was such an ordinary sound. I wanted the whole conversation to be ordinary too. I wanted to find one sentence that made this small enough to live with.

Eric said he loved me. He said he’d pictured our future. He said he bought a ring and planned to propose at our anniversary dinner next month. I hadn’t seen the ring, and I didn’t ask where it was. I didn’t want a ring to become the thing we used to avoid the question.

“I love you too,” I said.

He looked relieved for a second. Then I asked, “Can you take the list back as a condition of proposing?”

He said, “It isn’t a condition.”

“But you said I needed to work on those things before we could take the next step.”

“I said I wanted us to be at our best.”

I told him I could be considerate. I wouldn’t deliberately burp in his face. I’d clean up after myself. I could close the bathroom door because I already did. I could listen if he told me something bothered him.

“But I can’t promise I’ll never do something embarrassing,” I said. “And I don’t want to get engaged thinking I have to keep proving I’m feminine enough.”

Eric’s mouth opened, then closed. He looked at the phone again.

“I thought you’d understand what I meant,” he said.

That was the part I couldn’t work around. He was not saying the list had been a mistake that he no longer believed in. He was saying the words weren’t meant to sound like rules, even though he still wanted the things on the list.

I asked, “What happens when I’m not at my best?”

Eric shook his head. “I told you, I’d support you.”

“Would you still find me desirable?”

He looked down. “I don’t know how to answer that.”

I didn’t yell. I didn’t cry right away, either. I just felt how tired I was of trying to make the question fair enough for him to answer.

“I can’t marry someone who sees normal things as a failure of effort,” I said. “I’m not ending this over one burp. I’m ending it because this is what you think marriage asks of me.”

Eric said he loved me. I believe that he did. He said he’d hoped we could work it out, and I believed that too. But I couldn’t make the answer different by loving him harder.

I told him I was ending the relationship.

He looked at me for a long moment. “You’re sure?”

“No,” I said. “But I’m clear.”

He asked if I wanted time. I said I’d already taken time. I’d asked the question because I needed to know what he believed, not because I wanted to catch him saying something wrong.

He stood up slowly. “I don’t think this is what I’m asking you to do.”

“I know you don’t.”

That hurt more than if he’d called me dramatic. He still saw his expectation as a small request. I saw the years after it: getting sick, growing older, living in a house together, maybe having a baby, and trying to decide which parts of myself were safe to show.

I told him not to propose at our anniversary dinner. He said he wouldn’t. I didn’t ask to see the ring or tell him what to do with it. If he’d bought one, it was his to handle.

“I need space,” I said. “Please don’t call or come over for now.”

He nodded. We hugged at the door, which was probably a mistake, but I couldn’t bring myself to be cold. Then he left.

I didn’t feel brave. I felt like I’d just cancelled plans that had been in my head for years. The house we’d talked about, the dinners with our families, the small habits of being together. None of that suddenly became fake because I ended it.

The anniversary dinner didn’t happen. Eric didn’t propose. We haven’t talked since that night. I don’t know whether the ring existed, and I don’t need to know in order to make my decision.

The flowers stayed on the counter for another day. I finally put them in the trash, one stem at a time, because the water had started to smell.

I still miss him. I still think about how normal it felt to plan a life with him. But I know what I was choosing between now. It wasn’t one burp and almost four years. It was whether I could accept the terms he attached to marriage, and I couldn’t.