My hand was still on the knob when the key wouldn’t turn. There was a toothpick jammed into the lock, snapped off flush with the metal. I’d just finished a twelve-hour shift at the hospital, and I stood on my porch with my lunch bag cutting into my fingers, trying not to swear loud enough for the neighbors to hear.
I called my brother Martin because he lived six minutes away and had tools. He came over, got the toothpick out, and opened the door.
It seemed like a dumb prank. By the next night, it didn’t.
I should say I’m 51 and work nights as a nurse at a small hospital in a paper-mill town in Maine. Martin’s 55. We grew up ten minutes from where I live now, in a house our mother owned until she died. I bought my own place across town, a little cape with a narrow porch and one maple tree out front.
Martin has always been the handy one. If a hinge squeaked or a pipe made a noise, he’d show up with his old metal toolbox and fix it before I’d found the number for a plumber. I used to tease him that he needed to be useful to feel loved. He’d say, “Could be worse things.”
The first time, he found a pair of needle-nose pliers and pulled the toothpick out in pieces. He smelled like motor oil and the peppermint gum he chewed in the car.
“Probably a kid,” he said.
“Why would a kid do that?”
“Because kids are idiots.”
I laughed, mostly because I was tired. I made him tea even though neither of us wanted tea. We stood at the counter while the kettle clicked off, and I told him about a patient who’d called me by her sister’s name for most of the night. Martin asked if I’d eaten. I said I had. I hadn’t.
He watched me put the tea bag in the mug. “You need to get that lock changed.”
“I just got it changed last year.”
“Then get it changed again.”
I didn’t. I had a shift the next night, and I wanted to sleep. That was how I handled most things then. If I could put them off until after one more shift, I did.
The next evening, I came home at 11:18 and found another toothpick in the same lock.
This one had been pushed deeper. I remember noticing a splinter of pale wood on the porch mat, and thinking, stupidly, that I should sweep it up before it got tracked inside.
Martin came back with his tools. He didn’t make the kid joke this time.
“Did you call the police?”
“No. It’s a toothpick.”
“It’s somebody touching your lock.”
“I know what it is.”
He pulled it out, then looked down the street. The houses were dark, except for the one across from me where someone had left a kitchen light on. I felt silly standing there in my scrubs, but I also didn’t want to go inside alone.
So Martin stayed while I checked the windows. He waited on the porch until I locked the door from inside. Then he tapped twice on the glass, the way he used to when we were kids and he wanted me to come out.
“Call me if it happens again,” he said.
It happened again the next night.
I found the toothpick before I even put my key in. My first thought was that I should call Martin. My second was that I was tired of being afraid in my own doorway. I called him anyway.
He came over and got the toothpick out. He didn’t talk much. I noticed he kept looking at the tree near the sidewalk, like he expected someone to be behind it. I asked if he’d seen anybody.
“No.”
“You sure?”
“Yeah.”
I felt bad for asking. He had driven over in socks and work boots, and his hair was still flat from the knit cap he wore to bed. I told him I was sorry. He said, “Don’t be.”
The following day, while I was making coffee, I got a text from Martin. He said he had an idea. He could put a small camera in the maple tree, facing the porch. He had one at his house and didn’t need it there anymore. He’d take it down and set it up at mine.
I said yes. I told myself I was saying yes because I wanted to know who was doing it. That was true. But there was also a part of me that liked having Martin show up. I don’t love admitting that. He’d been calling less, and I’d been too busy to notice how much I missed it until I had a reason.
He came by before my shift and took the camera down from his place. It was small, gray, and easy to miss. He mounted it in the maple tree, high enough to see the door. He did it in a few minutes, then stood at the curb and checked the angle on his phone.
“You’ll get their face,” he said.
“Unless they wear a mask.”
“Then you’ll get a masked person.”
I thought that was funny at the time. He said he’d check the footage remotely in the morning. I told him I could check it myself. He said he’d already set up the app on my phone.
That night, nothing happened. The porch was empty. I checked the footage before bed, then again when I woke up. I couldn’t say why. Maybe I had started treating the camera like a patient monitor, something I needed to glance at before I could relax.
The next evening, another toothpick was in the lock.
I stood there with the key in my hand, staring at the tiny piece of wood. I didn’t touch it. I went inside through the back door, locked it behind me, and checked the camera.
The first hour showed nothing. A car passed. A cat crossed the porch. At 10:42, a person walked into frame wearing a dark jacket and a knit cap. The person stopped in front of my door, looked up at the tree, and turned away.
Then he came back.
I knew the way he walked before I saw his face. Martin leaned close to the lock and worked at it with his fingers. He took something from his pocket. A toothpick. He pushed it in, snapped it off, and stood there for a few seconds.
Then he looked up at the camera.
He didn’t look surprised. He just stared at it, like he knew exactly where it was.
I watched the clip twice. I might have watched it a third time. Then I called him.
“Did you see the footage?” I asked.
He didn’t answer right away.
“Yeah,” he said.
“Why did you do that?”
“I can explain.”
“Did you put the other ones in, too?”
“Yes.”
The word came out so plainly that I had to ask him to repeat it. He said yes again. He asked if he could come over. I told him not to. Then I called in sick for my shift, which was a bad call. I didn’t have a fever. I was just too angry to sleep and too tired to pretend I wasn’tI wasn’t sleeping when Martin came over anyway. I let him in, but I kept my phone in my hand with the footage ready. He looked at it once, then sat down without taking off his coat.
“I wanted you to call me,” he said.
“You could’ve just called me.”
“I did. You were always working.”
That was true, and it wasn’t the whole truth. I’d let his calls go to voicemail plenty of times. I’d also thanked him for fixing things more often than I’d asked how he was doing. He said he knew the toothpicks were wrong. He said he’d planned to stop after the first night, but I’d called again, and for a few minutes each time he got to be my brother instead of the person I remembered only when something broke.
I changed the lock the next morning and gave Martin the old key. I haven’t given him the new one. He still calls sometimes. I answer more than I used to, though not always. The last time he came by, he saw the camera was gone and asked if I was still afraid.
I said, “Not of the door.”