The old brass key felt cold against my fingers, and I could smell the fryer grease from my work shirt while I tried to get inside. The lock wouldn’t turn. I’d put a toothpick in it myself.
I did it three nights in a row. I know how that sounds. I know Pavel came over after long days of his own, carrying his toolbox, because I told him somebody was messing with my door. I let him worry about me. I did that.
I’m not proud of it, and I’m not going to tell you I had no choice. I had one. I could have called my brother and said I was lonely. Instead, I made him think I was in danger.
I’m 58, and I work the evening shift packing medical supplies at a place outside New Castle, Pennsylvania. Pavel lives eight minutes away, in the small brick house where we both grew up. I bought my own little place after my divorce. I like having my things where I put them. I like knowing nobody will ask why I’m tired.
I’ve been in this country since I was 19. My mother taught me that if something needed doing, you did it before anyone had to ask. Pavel learned the same thing. For years we were the two people in the family who showed up early, stayed late, and didn’t talk much about what it cost.
We used to have coffee at his kitchen table every Sunday. His wife, Nadja, would put out a plate of toast and sliced cheese. Pavel always cut the crust off my piece because I’d complained about it once when we were kids. I don’t know why I remember that. I do.
Then Nadja got sick. It wasn’t one big thing. There were appointments, pills, and days when Pavel had to help her get up from a chair. I visited. I brought soup. I also got irritated when plans changed, which I’m not proud to admit. I’d say, “Call me when you know,” like his whole life was a schedule he had failed to keep.
Nadja died two years ago. Pavel went quiet after that. He still answered when I called, but the Sunday coffee stopped. I told myself he wanted space. I also didn’t ask him to come over, because I didn’t want to be one more person needing something from him.
So the toothpick idea was not about a broken lock. It was about making a reason.
The first night, I came home at 9:40 and couldn’t turn the key. I tried the knob once, then again, harder. The porch light had a moth beating against it. I remember thinking the lock was probably worn out. I didn’t think “toothpick.” Not yet.
I called Pavel. He picked up on the fourth ring.
“My key won’t go,” I said.
“Did you try the other key?”
“I don’t have another one.”
He came over in his work pants and a gray sweatshirt with a little hole near the cuff. I had seen that hole a hundred times. I still noticed it.
Pavel crouched by the lock. He used a small pair of pliers and a thin metal tool. The toothpick came out in two pieces. Pavel held them on his palm.
“Somebody put this in here,” he said.
“Why would somebody do that?”
He looked at the lock, then at me. “I don’t know. Don’t use the door until I check it.”
I nodded. I asked him to stay for tea. He said he couldn’t, because Nadja’s sister was bringing over some things and he needed to be home. I said, “Of course,” in a way that made him hear I was hurt.
He gave me a look. “I said I can’t tonight.”
“I heard you.”
He put the tools away and left. I stood in the doorway until his car turned at the corner. Then I went inside and sat at the kitchen table with my coat still on.
The next evening, I came home and the key wouldn’t turn again. That time, I knew.
I waited in the car for a few minutes, telling myself I was being foolish. Then I called Pavel.
“It’s happening again,” I said.
“What is?”
“The lock. Somebody put something in it again.”
He came over, but this time he didn’t make a joke or ask if I had tried the other key. He checked the lock and found another toothpick. I stayed beside him, arms folded, acting scared. The whole time, I could feel the point of the lie pressing into my throat.
“Maybe you should call the police,” Pavel said.
“I don’t want trouble.”
“It already is trouble.”
I said I’d think about it. That was a lie too.
Pavel took the toothpick inside and set it on my kitchen counter. It was so ordinary, a cheap wooden thing with one end bent. I thought about throwing it away. I left it there. I wanted Pavel to see it when he came back.
That’s not a good thing to admit. But it’s true.
I’d bought the toothpicks at the grocery store near work. The little plastic container sat by my sink. I had used them for years, mostly to get food out of my teeth after dinner. I remember the container being almost empty. That is the sort of detail my mind kept. Not what I was doing to my brother. Just the container.
Pavel came by the following afternoon with a small camera. He said the camera was from his place and he could hide it in a tree near the front walk.
“I don’t want the neighbors seeing a camera pointed at my house,” I said.
“They won’t see it.”
“Is that even legal?”
“It’s your yard. We’re not putting it inside.”
I looked at the camera in his hand. I could have stopped him right there. I could have said, “Don’t bother. Nobody’s doing this.”
Instead I said, “All right.”
He worked on the camera while I stood inside the door. I watched him reach into the branches and adjust it. His jacket caught on a twig. He pulled it loose and laughed at himself.
“Can you see the lock?” I asked.
“I can see the door.”
“Good.”
He said, “If something happens, we’ll know.”
The words should have been enough to make me back out. They weren’t. I wanted him to keep coming. I wanted someone to check on me without my having to say I was having a hard time. I knew that was not fair to him. I did it anyway.
I had been lonely in a plain, embarrassing way. Not the kind where you cry every night. The kind where you eat toast standing at the counter because sitting down alone makes supper feel too much like a real meal. I talked to the cashier at the pharmacy longer than I needed to. I watched the phone after work and told myself I was waiting for a work message.
Pavel had his grief. I had mine, though mine wasn’t as big. My marriage had ended years before. My daughter, Milena, lived in Erie and had two children. She called when she could. I was proud of being the mother who didn’t ask for too much. Then I got mad when nobody guessed what I needed.
I’m explaining this because it was part of it, not because it makes what I did fine.
That evening, I put the toothpick in the lock again. I waited until the porch light came on. Then I called Pavel and told him I was scared to go outside.
He said, “Stay in the car. I’m coming.”
I sat with both hands on the steering wheel. The key was still in the lock. I could have pulled it out and gone inside. I didn’t.
Pavel came over and checked the lock. He found the toothpick. He didn’t say much. He took it out, put it in his pocket, and went home.
He didn’t invite me for coffee on Sunday.
The next few days were quiet. I went to work, came home, watched television. I did not call him. I was waiting for Pavel to decide on his own that I deserved company. That is how childish I was being.
The camera caught me on the fourth night.
I knew the time because I had just come back from the late grocery run. It was around 8:17. I had a bag with apples and a loaf of bread. I set it down on the passenger seat, took out a toothpick, and walked to the door.
I had used a toothpick from the container by my sink. I had brought it in my pocket. I pressed it into the keyhole, snapped it off, and pulled my hand away.
Then I looked up at the camera.
I don’t remember deciding to look. I did it anyway. I stood there for a second, with my work coat zipped to my chin, and went back to the car.
The next morning, Pavel called and asked me to come over.
“I have the footage,” he said.
My hands were wet from washing dishes. I dried them on a towel and said, “What footage?”
“Come over, please.”
I drove there. I knew before I got out of the car. I knew from his voice. Still, I went in like I thought there could be some other answer.
Pavel had the camera’s memory card in his hand. We sat at the kitchen table where Nadja used to set out toast. He had made coffee, but neither of us touched it.
“I saw it,” he said.
I looked at the card. “You saw what?”
He didn’t answer. He put the card in his laptop and turned the screen toward me.
The video showed my car pulling up. It showed me getting out. It showed me holding the toothpick. It showed my hand at the lock, then my face turning toward the camera.
I watched the whole thing, though there was no reason to. I knew what I’d done. Still, I watched myself do it.
Pavel paused the video.
“You put it there,” he said.
I tried to say something. I couldn’t get the words lined up.
“You called me three times,” he said. “You let me think somebody was trying to get into your house.”
“I know.”
“Why?”
That was the question I had been avoiding since the first night. I looked down at my hands. One fingernail had a little split at the corner. I started picking at it, then stopped.
“I wanted you to come over,” I said.
Pavel leaned back. He didn’t yell. I think that made it worse.
“You could have called me,” he said.
I said, “I thought you were busy.”
“I am busy.”
“I know.”
“But I would have come.”
I looked at him then. His eyes were tired. I’d seen that tiredness after Nadja died. I had been careful not to mention it because I was afraid he’d ask me to do something, and because I didn’t know how to help without taking over.
Pavel tapped the laptop once with his finger. “I came every time.”
“I know.”
“Why did you make me worry?”
I wanted to say I was lonely. I wanted to say I didn’t know what else to do. I wanted to say he had stopped coming around and I didn’t know how to ask for him back. All of that was true. None of it answered the question.
“I wanted you to notice me,” I said.
Pavel closed the laptop.
“I did notice you.”
That was all. No big speech. No shouting. The truth was small and plain.
I started crying then, in the ugly way where you try to keep your mouth closed and your face doesn’t listen. I was angry with myself for crying. I had made the problem, and now I was making him sit through my tears too.
Pavel slid a paper napkin across the table. It had a little blue flower printed on it. Nadja used to buy those. I took it and wiped under my nose.
“I’m sorry,” I said.
He nodded once, but didn’t say it was all right.
That hurt. It should have.
Pavel took the camera down that afternoon. I went with him, though I didn’t ask him to. He reached into the tree and brought it down, then held it in his hand while we stood by the front walk.
“I’ll get a new lock,” I said.
“I’ll help you change it.”
“You don’t have to.”
“I know.”
He helped anyway. We bought the lock at the hardware store. I paid for it. When we got home, Pavel changed it while I held the small screws in my palm. The new key turned smoothly. I tried it once, then again.
I wanted to say something that would fix the morning. I didn’t have the words. I asked if he wanted coffee.
“Not today,” he said.
I nearly answered with my old sharp voice. Instead I said, “Okay.”
For a few weeks, we didn’t have Sunday coffee. Pavel texted to ask how the new lock was working. I answered honestly. It worked. He did not come over to check it.
I still had the little toothpick container by the sink. I thought about throwing it away, but that felt like pretending the problem was in the container. So I left it there. I haven’t used one to open anything since.
Pavel and I started talking again, slowly. We ate lunch once at a place by the highway. We talked about Milena’s kids and the price of eggs. We didn’t talk about the camera. Not that day.
I still catch myself wanting to make a reason when what I want is company. I’m not saying I’ve become good at asking. I haven’t. I just know what it costs when I turn a need into a lie.
Last Sunday, Pavel came by without me calling. He had two coffees in a cardboard tray and a bag of toast from the bakery. He handed me the one with no crust, the way he used to.
I almost said, “You didn’t have to.”
I didn’t.
I took the coffee and let him come in.